Updated March 27 at 9:27am

Justices question health law’s constitutionality

'Those who don't participate make it expensive.'

Bloomberg News
Several U.S. Supreme Court justices questioned the constitutionality of the requirement in President Barack Obama’s health care law that Americans acquire insurance or pay a penalty. More

To continue reading this article, please do one of the following.



Sign up to receive Providence Business News' newsletters
and breaking news alerts.  

HEALTH INSURANCE

Justices question health law’s constitutionality

'Those who don't participate make it expensive.'

Posted:

Several U.S. Supreme Court justices questioned the constitutionality of the requirement in President Barack Obama’s health care law that Americans acquire insurance or pay a penalty.

“The federal government is not supposed to be a government that has all powers,” Justice Antonin Scalia said early in the March 27 two-hour argument on Obama’s signature legislative victory. “It’s supposed to be a government of limited powers.”

Justice Anthony Kennedy said the requirement to obtain health coverage is telling individuals they “must act.” Kennedy, who most often occupies the court’s ideological middle ground, said, “That changes the relationship of the government to the individual in a fundamental way.”

“Do you not have a heavy burden” to show the law is authorized by the Constitution, Kennedy asked U.S. Solicitor General Donald Verrilli, who argued in the law’s defense.

The March 27 session was the second of three days of Supreme Court hearings held last week on Obama’s health care law. Twenty-six states say Congress exceeded its authority in approving the 2010 law, which would extend insurance to 32 million people and revamp an industry that accounts for 18 percent of the U.S. economy.

The court will likely rule in late June.

Verrilli, the Obama administration’s top Supreme Court lawyer, Verrilli contended that Congress can require people to buy insurance under its constitutional power to regulate the interstate health care market.

People who don’t buy health insurance and can’t afford to pay for care themselves are guaranteed emergency-room treatment when they need it, Verrilli said. People who have insurance are subsidizing them, he said.

040212 Focus: INSURANCE, insurance, health insurance, law, politics, government, focus, resident Barack Obama’s health care law, insurance, health insurance, law, politics, government, 26~52, Issue4212Export.pbn
Next Page

Comments

No comments on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment
Latest News